A spacious green garden beneath a mature live oak, with tropical planting and a glimpse of an ivory stucco home in Coconut Grove.

What Coconut Grove's Recent Home Sales Say About the Price of a Lot

In July 2026, two houses on Calusa Street in Coconut Grove sold within a few weeks of each other. At 2800 Calusa St., a 6,393-square-foot house built in 2025 sold for $8.1 million, about $1,267 per square foot. At 2777 Calusa St., a 765-square-foot house built in 1947 sold for $3.1 million, about $4,052 per square foot.

The older house has one and a half baths, and the new house has six and a half. Per foot, the older house cost more than three times as much.

The house itself explains only part of a price like that. The likeliest explanation is the ground under it, and that changes how a buyer should compare homes in the Grove.

The Q3 deed records, oldest to newest

Haute Residence's Q3 2026 Coconut Grove report lists every recorded residential sale of $2 million or more in ZIP 33133 with a sale date between July 1 and September 30, 2026. There were 57 sales, with a median price of $3.15 million and an average of $1,435 per interior square foot. Single-family houses made up 41 of the 57 sales and about 75% of the dollar volume.

The table below lists some of those single-family sales in order of when the house was built. Every row has a Q3 2026 sale date in the deed records.

Address Year built Interior sq. ft. Sale price Price per sq. ft.
2980 Bird Ave. 1922 1,064 $2,100,000 $1,974
3170 Florida Ave. 1944 1,088 $3,120,000 $2,868
2777 Calusa St. 1947 765 $3,100,000 $4,052
4152 Battersea Rd. 1947 1,810 $4,475,000 $2,472
3431 Poinciana Ave. 1955 2,195 $4,500,000 $2,050
4095 Hardie Ave. 2025 3,874 $5,000,000 $1,291
2800 Calusa St. 2025 6,393 $8,100,000 $1,267
2175 SW 25th St. 2025 3,679 $2,790,000 $758

Each of the five older houses sold for more per square foot than any of the three 2025 builds in the table. Two of them, on Calusa Street and Florida Avenue, are under 1,100 square feet and sold for about $3.1 million each, close to the quarter's median. A buyer paying for rooms would not pay the median for 765 square feet. Those prices make sense only as payments for a Grove address and the land that comes with it.

The data has limits. The report counts by ZIP code, which does not match the neighborhood as residents draw it, and deed records can be filed late. The source has not confirmed whether its sale date is the closing date or the recording date. Even so, the older houses in the table sell for more per foot than the new ones in every case.

The new house's price is mostly land

Construction cost fills in the rest of the picture. In a November 9 Coconut Grove Spotlight story, Levy Builders estimated luxury custom new construction in Miami at $350 to $650 per square foot.

Compare that with 2800 Calusa at $1,267 per foot. Even at the top of Levy's range, construction would cover only about half of what the buyer paid. The rest is the lot, the street and the developer's margin. A new Grove house is also largely a land purchase. The land cost is spread over more square feet, so the price per foot looks lower.

Location moves the land price. 2175 SW 25th St. and 4040 Kiaora St. were both built in 2025, but one sold for $758 per foot and the other for $2,632. 4040 Kiaora sold for $22.5 million, the highest recorded sale of the quarter. The Miami Herald reported that Sabal Development sold the house and that it is not on the water. PROFILEmiami reported that Sabal's construction arm, Sabal Luxury Builder, designed and built it, with 8,833 square feet of interior space.

Grove lots also vary widely in size. In October, The Real Deal reported a $17.4 million contract on an existing house at 3373 Poinciana Ave., on a 50,000-square-foot lot.

Three ways to buy the same ground

If the lot is most of the price, a Grove purchase comes down to what you want on it.

A finished new house costs the least per foot, because the land and construction costs are spread over a large floor plan. The three 2025 builds in the table sold for $758 to $1,291 per foot, well below the older houses. Many new Grove houses are the white, boxy designs the Spotlight says are known locally as "sugar cube" homes.

An older house can also be bought mainly for its lot. A local agent team told the Spotlight that sellers seeking the highest price usually end up selling to a developer who will tear down the structure.

Restoring and expanding the original house is the third option. The same Spotlight story covers TROPICA, a Coconut Grove architecture and landscape firm founded in 2019. It is designing and rebuilding nine cottages from the 1920s to the 1940s across the North, South and Center Grove. Its first project, at Trapp Avenue and Lucaya Street, joins an 825-square-foot cottage from 1925 to a 7,000-square-foot addition in a matching style. On Gifford Lane in the Center Grove, a family dropped their plan to tear down a 100-year-old house. In the new design, the old living room, with its coral rock fireplace, becomes a courtyard.

The construction cost ranges overlap. TROPICA's rebuilds average $500 to $800 per square foot, and Levy's estimate for new construction is $350 to $650, so restoration runs about $150 higher per foot at each end of the range. The agent team quoted in the story said a well-restored cottage could sell for more per square foot than a new build.

The block and the canopy are part of what you buy

Demolitions in the Grove get close attention in local news. In July, the Spotlight reported that a South Grove homeowner is seeking historic recognition for her 1925 house, and that preservation advocate Christine Rupp said demolitions have left parts of the Grove "unrecognizable." In August, the Spotlight's coverage of Charles Avenue quoted residents describing bungalows being replaced by pricier new houses, and a board member of Preserve the West Grove commenting on the effect of smaller approvals.

For a buyer, the practical point is that a block where cottages still stand looks and feels different from a block that has mostly been rebuilt. Before you make an offer, walk the street and see how many original houses are left on it.

Mature trees are part of the same conversation. The city's Tree Ordinance Advisory Committee is meeting this fall. On November 12, the Spotlight reported that the Builders Association of South Florida had presented its recommendations to the committee. The committee expects to send its own recommendations to the City Commission by next March. If you are paying for a lot in order to build, have your architect walk the site and look at the trees before you settle on a price.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do some small older houses in Coconut Grove cost so much per square foot? In the Q3 2026 deed records, a 765-square-foot house built in 1947 sold for $3.1 million, close to the quarter's $3.15 million median for sales of $2 million or more. A price like that is paying mainly for the land and the address, not the house.

Is restoring a Grove cottage cheaper than building new? The reported ranges overlap. The Spotlight reported in November 2026 that TROPICA's rebuilds average $500 to $800 per square foot, and that Levy Builders estimates $350 to $650 for luxury custom new construction in Miami.

How many higher-end homes are on the market in the Grove? Haute Residence counted 33 listings at $2 million or more in its October 14, 2026 snapshot. The median asking price was $4.35 million, at $1,561 per square foot, and the average listing had been on the market 14.6 days.

If you're weighing a Grove cottage against a new build, start with the lot and what you plan to do with it. Maxim Properties can pull recent sales on the Miami streets you're considering, and our in-house financing team can structure the purchase around whether you plan to keep, restore or rebuild. Schedule a consultation and bring the addresses you're considering.

Work With Us

Stay ahead with the latest insights, expert advice, and exclusive updates from The Maxim Team. Subscribe now to get valuable real estate tips, market trends, and more delivered straight to your inbox!

Follow Me on Instagram